This thread has been going on for quite a while, and it's been several months since somebody decided to post. All the same, as a newcomer, I would like to weigh in.

What is intriguing, and complicating, is that with the internet we are now a world community: the ideas and norms of one country are juxtaposed to the tastes and standards of others in different regions and cultures. So we have the Dutch euthenizing their elderly, but that is anathema in Alabama. And if spanking a child is discipline in Montana, it's erotic in England, and a crime in Sweeden. Complicated, huh?

So it's no surprise that sex/kindky sex/violent sex/teenage sex is going to be complicated! And Kallie is right: one person's "personal fetish" is another person's "dangerous, illegal perversion," and vice-versa!

It comes down to: the webmaster makes the rules and enforces the rules. It's his butt that will be hung out to dry, depending on where he is located.

Now, some thoughts for Sirthumper. I kind of like your scenario, because nc sex with early-to-mid teens is a fantasy many of us share. For starters, it's awfully trite to "have them case her place." I'd look for a fresher way to move this plot. Face it: middle-aged guys hanging around some girl's home, however surepticiously, are going to get noticed by somebody, who will call the cops for an I.D. check, at the very least.

Anyway, here's some ideas for making your story--if you write it yourself--more acceptable. Consider posting it on other sites. asstr.org and mrdoubles.com come to mind. "mrdoubles" has LOTS of pre-teen and young-teen stories, most of them involving incest, but lots of them don't. And quite a few are non-consensual.

Another is to put the girl a bit older to conform to bdsmlibrary's standards, but make her very innocent and virginal. Perhaps she was brought up in a boarding convent school. Or very protected by zealously religious parents. How about making her an athlete, a ballet student, or something, who has never had a social life to speak of, busy as she's been?

Two other ideas to make your idea work for a 17-18 year old innocent and pure victim: she was carefully protected by a guardian who wanted to "save her for himself" upon attaining her "maturity," or, is mildly retarded: an 18-year-old with the mind of a 12-year-old.*

So, there's an idea for you to work with!

*I must point out that in the eyes of most American states' law, sex with a mentally disabled person is also considered "statutory rape."