Kadence, I think that there are a variety of different readers--thus a variety of different preferred styles. You won't ever please everyone, but if your story is good it will find its audience. Some prefer 1-dimensional characters and sex from the second paragraph while others complain when no background or "leading-up-to" events are described. Your story will appeal to the latter type of reader.

Maddie; I have to ask it.. what is "reverse peanut butter cup?"