The calculator represents the accepted norm in this scenario. It works exactly like the acceptable dress standards by which the dom in the very first post in this thread judges his sub to be a slut. The accepted standard of female dress suggests that the sub is dressed like a slattern or common whore. So she's a "bad girl" even though it was her dom who wanted her to dress this way.
I see the problem, though. It is easily fixed. Replace "The calculator says it is four" with "The calculator says it SHOULD BE four." Then it works almost exactly the same way. That said, the
2 + 2 = 5 example was never meant to be reasonable. It was meant to show that the dom is intentionally unreasonable...and it doesn't matter because it's all a pretext to
initiate some hot fucking. Subs who say they would object to a Dom doing this are free to find a Dom who doesn't like this sort of play.
- FS