Quote Originally Posted by BDSM_Tourguide
Play-Doh tears apart far to oeasily to make a good plug, I would think. Also, rubber cement is VERY toxic and can be absorbed through your rectum. This could make you quite sick.
I've never experienced any tearing. As long as you wait until it hardens, then put a condom over it, no problems. I also put in a little bullet vibe into one, and it worked perfectly. That is why a layer of glue helps. At the time I had rubber cement, and as I stated in my post, I wouldn't use it unless I put a condom over it, especially if it's homemade. The smell of it is toxic, so obviously the glue is. Give me a lil credit here, you think I'd actually put glue in my butt?

As for the liquid latex, in layers you don't have a problem, but if you just make a mold and try to fill it with it, drying becomes a real issue. If you want to take the candle approach and dip it quite a few times, I suppose it may work, but it could take a while, drying between layers and such.