(for some reason the thing posted WHILE I was typing... Bugs bugs, where is Llabmik when he is needed!)
... accessing the story again can be a pain.
Why not put a review template in TXT or Word or XLS format on the homepage. People could DL it, review any number of stories at leisure, then email the forms to a dedicated email box. Parsing for results would be automated, and individual reviews would be made available for browsing.
Sorry for the mistake.