Do you believe in miracles?

[Thorne]

Isn't that a bit narrow definition of Miracle? How about miracles as "the incomprehensible"?

No, incomprehensible means just that: we cannot comprehend it. That doesn't make it a miracle. Just unknown.

The Bible claims that Jesus walked on water, and proclaims it a miracle. A thousand years later if someone walked on water they would be executed as a witch. Now, if you see that it's probably David Blaine. Where's the miracle?

[TomOfSweden]

No, incomprehensible means just that: we cannot comprehend it. That doesn't make it a miracle. Just unknown.

The Bible claims that Jesus walked on water, and proclaims it a miracle. A thousand years later if someone walked on water they would be executed as a witch. Now, if you see that it's probably David Blaine. Where's the miracle?

That wasn't convincing. I still don't see a difference. All religious miracles are not only of unknown origin but also undetectable. How more unknown do you want to get?!?